Feedback profile - Collin Lyle

Feedback summary

Positive Positive
Neutral Neutral
Negative Negative
Feedback score
23 (+22 /0 /-1)
Positive feedback (last 12 months)
0%
Received as seller
Received as buyer
Left for others
I am a trader posting feedback on Collin Lyle as trader
Negative
Sent a dropped dented bass with damage to knobs and battery compartment (both loose) bass crackles. I returned it and he sent it back *again*
Classified ad: For sale Ibanez EHB1005SMS
Standalone
Standalone
Video of damage -


Seller disclosed mods to preamp only after basses were in transit.

"I forgot to mention something: There's a little switch on the preamp that changes the sound slightly (in what way I can't remember). I can't remember if I switched it back after trying it out or liked the difference and left it.

Anyway, it's worth playing with to see which setting you prefer."

I was friendly in my communications, and clear in my request that my bass be sent back to me. Seller did offer to pay for repairs, but the tone of the offer left me concerned about trusting that seller was good for cost of repairs -- and a repair to the drop would of course be impractical. I asked for my bass back and returned his to him UPS. Seller sent his broken bass back to me *again* a second time instead of returning mine.

Actually I think I'm wrong about it being a switch. I'm pretty sure it's terminating the connections to different sockets. Circled in red in the attached photo.

I'll see if I can find the info about that again. It's been a few years.

standalone said:
(message one) Ok so I’ve plugged the bass in and I’m getting crackling with the output both with in active and passive mode.

(message two) The battery box is loose, as is one of the concentric knobs which doesn’t turn well, and there is a dent along the bottom right under the cavity rout from being dropped.

(message three)I first heard crackling when the active EQ was engaged. I thought, ok no problem, its the battery. I switched it to passive. And still heard it. I cannot isolate it, I am not sure if it is in the preamp, battery compartment, or the jack. I will run a full check with another cable, but I played a three hour two set gig with that cable on Saturday and had no issue.

The pot is not only sticking, which is something concentrics do, but it's absolutely loose and rattling around. When I get home I will photograph the indentation and paint marks from the bottom of the bass -- right next to that broken pot.

As it is, I cannot use the bass and cannot sell it, and I'm out $290 on top of that.

I truly do not have time or the resources to take the bass in for repair, and as it is, with the drop that I'd certainly have to disclose in any sale, I've experienced a big loss on this trade. We don't even know what soldering was done in the electronics.

I've lost a bass that I take on every gig with me and traded for a pig in a poke.

The way I see it, the basses need to be sent back to where they came from and I should be refunded shipping for both and my $150. I paid $20 extra for insurance and $20 extra penalty for the trapezoidal box, which was my decision and I'm fine with not including that.

That will be about $350.

Apologies for not responding earlier, I've been on the road since I left for my gig Satuday afternoon

(message four)I understand the offer you are making to pay for the repairs, but my life is such that I do not have time for repairing your bass. This should have been done before selling or trading the bass, or declared honestly before making a deal.

The bass is on the way back to you. Tracking number is 1ZH562V80300017418

I would hope that you do the right thing and return my bass to me, and restore my $150 "value difference" that you asked for, as well as the shipping I have spent in this unfortunate deal.

I'm disappointed to see my friendly, conciliatory way with folks used against me, as in your response above. If your mod was working and the bass was in giggable or salable condition, I'd have accepted this. That is not the case.

I was able to find a discount in shipping the bass back to you, at $76.00. I spent about $140 shipping my bass to you. But I won't hold you responsible for my own busy-ness and need to ship at a premium, so I will only ask for you to cover my shipping each way at that reduced cost -- so, $75 times 2 plus the $150 I sent to you for the now clearly incorrect "value difference" -- total:

$300.

This does leave me out about $70, and is entirely fair. And I'd like my bass returned to me at:(snip)

My position has been clear and has not changed.

I sent you a working bass without issues. I will not take responsibility for damage outside of my control without the opportunity to recoup my costs. I offered to handle the repairs for said damage even though I wasn't responsible. You refused the offer.

You're busy? So am I. I offered to handle all of the communications with the repair shop so that all you had to do was drop it off. You refused. Your lack of time is irrelevant and isn't my financial burden.

The EHB1005SMS is your bass. You sealed that when you took it upon yourself to subject it to possible additional shipping damage.

Thank you for reading this feedback.
I am a buyer posting feedback on Collin Lyle as seller
Positive
Great seller! Pedal Packaged safe and arrived quickly
Stephenw56
Stephenw56
Thanks again!
I am a buyer posting feedback on Collin Lyle as seller
Positive
Above & Beyond
Classified ad: For sale Sandberg California VS Lionel
pwilson
pwilson
Guitar exactly as described, plus Collin dealt with paypal issues, put flats on for me, packed well and shipped quickly. Good communication through the process, zero issues. Great TalkBasser.
I am a buyer posting feedback on Collin Lyle as seller
Positive
Easy transaction
agentcooper2001
agentcooper2001
Quick shipping, pedal in excellent condition. Thanks!
I am a buyer posting feedback on Collin Lyle as seller
Positive
Very smooth intl. transaction. Friendly seller. Recommended!
Classified ad: For sale Southampton Utility Knife
Mr_BK
Mr_BK
Everything in this deal was perfect.
I am a buyer posting feedback on Collin Lyle as seller
Positive
Excellent transaction
Shamwow
Shamwow
Collin is great to deal with, very responsive and direct with communication. The transaction was a local pick up so we were able to chat face to face. Collin is a very genuine person and quite passionate about bass!
I am a seller posting feedback on Collin Lyle as buyer
Positive
Great Buyer
brocco
brocco
The sell went very smooth Collin sent money very fast.
I am a buyer posting feedback on Collin Lyle as seller
Positive
Great transaction and really fast shipping.
Classified ad: For sale WRA Goliath Tube Preamp/DI
C
CJL
Thanks!
I am a seller posting feedback on Collin Lyle as buyer
Positive
Smooth transaction, easy to deal with! Great TB'er!
Dr Greenthumb
Dr Greenthumb
Thanks again!
I am a buyer posting feedback on Collin Lyle as seller
Positive
Great pedal, great communication.
Classified ad: For sale Shift Line Olympic MKIIIs Preamp/DI
Rob Thompson
Rob Thompson
All good, thank you!
I am a seller posting feedback on Collin Lyle as buyer
Positive
Smooth transaction, would def do business with Collin again. A+
Iridescentone
Iridescentone
Fast pymt, good communication. Very nice person to do business with.

Thanks, Collin!
I am a buyer posting feedback on Collin Lyle as seller
Positive
Excellent transaction!
SlowpokeJoe
SlowpokeJoe
Great communication, excellent packaging and fast shipping! Buy with confidence!
I am a seller posting feedback on Collin Lyle as buyer
Positive
Excellent TBer!
Drkwdsman
Drkwdsman
Fast payment and gave good advice on shipping pedals as well. Definitely a good TBer to work with in the classified community.

Zach
Drkwdsman
I am a buyer posting feedback on Collin Lyle as seller
Positive
Great seller. Item was packed very well, and he had shipped the item within 2 hours of payment.
Classified ad: For sale Ciocks DC5
c5hokie
c5hokie
Great packing job. Seller got the item shipped within 2 hours of payment. Would definitely buy from him again.
I am a buyer posting feedback on Collin Lyle as seller
Positive
Haven't played it yet, but have high hopes!
Wfrance3
Wfrance3
Super fast shipping. Arrived today well packaged and in great shape!
I am a buyer posting feedback on Collin Lyle as seller
Positive
Great seller, great communication
Classified ad: For sale MXR Bass Envelope Filter
Griev
Griev
Shipped out quickly and well packed. Thanks again!
I am a buyer posting feedback on Collin Lyle as seller
Positive
Smooth Sailing
aglide
aglide
Collin shipped the pedal ASAP, it was packed very well, and it works perfectly.
I am a seller posting feedback on Collin Lyle as buyer
Positive
Great person to deal with
twinfallsbass
twinfallsbass
Prompt payment and overall great selling experience. Thanks!
I am a buyer posting feedback on Collin Lyle as seller
Positive
Cabinets performed as promised. Good communication. Great seller.
morebass!
morebass!
Cabinets performed as promised. Good communication. Great seller.
I am a buyer posting feedback on Collin Lyle as seller
Positive
great deal, exactly as described and lighting fast delivery. Great TB seller
Classified ad: For sale SolidGoldFX Beta DLX Overdrive
yobtaf
yobtaf
works perfect. thanks, think this is a keeper and i can sell off other pedals!