A Tribute to Dan Roberts, Bassist of the Crash Test Dummies

Dear Dan Roberts,

Your bass work on the album God Shuffled His Feet, the 1993 classic album from your band, the Crash Test Dummies, is perhaps one of the best achievements in modern pop/rock bass playing.

First, let me say that I am a huge fan of the album and have probably listened to it over 100 times. I keep running back to the album, over and over again, throughout all the years since 1993, mainly to satisfy my meth-like addiction to your kickin' bass lines provided throughout the tracks. Honestly, your bass work brings that album to another level and makes listening to it so enjoyable. Yes, the melodies and song crafting are impeccable (I always cry in shock when people think your band only had one hit, "MMM MMM MMM"). Yes, the baritone singing of your brother, Brad, the contrasting, high-pitch singing of Ellen Reid, and the patient, "give 'em space" drumming of Mitch Dorge, are all part of the magic formula that made the album sell 8 million copies, but, it is your bass work that stands out above all... Below are just a few reasons I admire your work:

1) Your bass lines work with the drums perfectly. A good band always has a rhythm section that collaborates together. You are in the pocket with the drummer. You are creating very good grooves that fill in the generous space provided by Mitch. Key examples are your work on "How Does a Duck Know?" and "I Think I'll Disappear Now"; they are fantastic.

2) Your bass lines are fun. You have imaginative, original fills peppered throughout the tracks. This album is one of my favorites because I thoroughly enjoy listening to the bass work. Its fresh. Your fills aren't designed to "show off" either. They are well-disciplined expressions that help guide each song along. I put you up there with Sir Paul McCartney in all of these respects. Every time I listen to this album I have to go play bass immediately after. Your work is inspirational.

3) Your bass lines are very creative; arguably genius. The note selection, rhythm, fills, etc., are very original and do each song a service. If you took each song from the album and asked AI to develop the perfect bass line for them, it would spit out your bass lines.

4) The "run" you do at the end of the titular song is EPIC.

5) I am not much of a tone guy, i.e. gear head, but I do enjoy your consistent natural bass tone throughout the album.

You are severely underrated, as many great bass players are. So this letter is to let you know that you are appreciated for your artistic ability, mechanics, and groove. You are a bass player's bass player. May God bless you, and may God bless the United States of America.
 
Last edited:
@megahog other than the songs that got airplay, Im not that familiar with Crash Test Dummies or Dan Roberts' work, but I enjoyed reading your post a lot. I like it when people express what they like best about an artist from the heart. welcome to Talkbass, I hope Dan reads your kind words. I'm putting on his work today so thank you for pointing me towards another solid bassist. Stay well.
 
@megahog other than the songs that got airplay, Im not that familiar with Crash Test Dummies or Dan Roberts' work, but I enjoyed reading your post a lot. I like it when people express what they like best about an artist from the heart. welcome to Talkbass, I hope Dan reads your kind words. I'm putting on his work today so thank you for pointing me towards another solid bassist. Stay well.
Hi thanks! This letter is the culmination of 15 years of respect and I feel relieved having unloaded all my thoughts! Glad you like it, you should definitely give the album a try. Their sound isn't for everyone, but that entire album, every track, is good. Its rare to find an album with no filler material and has nothing but great songs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: thedovewarlord
Cool stuff @megahog. I skipped around a few albums, I liked "Our Driver Gestures". Overall, Bass playing, and musicianship is there as you described across the board. The vocals on "gestures" gives me a a hint of Peter Murphy or Mark Lanegan which I liked.
 
You know, whats funny, I haven't deep dived into their full catalog. I need to. Its just this one album that had all the stars aligned and was perfect. I don't think they were able to recreate the magic that happened in their follow-up albums, but I am going to check them out soon. His voice is definitely unique. The only other baritone singers I can think off the bat are Cash and Leonard Cohen.
 
Dear Dan Roberts,

Your bass work on the album God Shuffled His Feet, the 1993 classic album from your band, the Crash Test Dummies, is perhaps one of the best achievements in modern pop/rock bass playing.

First, let me say that I am a huge fan of the album and have probably listened to it over 100 times. I keep running back to the album, over and over again, throughout all the years since 1993, mainly to satisfy my meth-like addiction to your kickin' bass lines provided throughout the tracks. Honestly, your bass work brings that album to another level and makes listening to it so enjoyable. Yes, the melodies and song crafting are impeccable (I always cry in shock when people think your band only had one hit, "MMM MMM MMM"). Yes, the baritone singing of your brother, Brad, the contrasting, high-pitch singing of Ellen Reid, and the patient, "give 'em space" drumming of Mitch Dorge, are all part of the magic formula that made the album sell 8 million copies, but, it is your bass work that stands out above all... Below are just a few reasons I admire your work:

1) Your bass lines work with the drums perfectly. A good band always has a rhythm section that collaborates together. You are in the pocket with the drummer. You are creating very good grooves that fill in the generous space provided by Mitch. Key examples are your work on "How Does a Duck Know?" and "I Think I'll Disappear Now"; they are fantastic.

2) Your bass lines are fun. You have imaginative, original fills peppered throughout the tracks. This album is one of my favorites because I thoroughly enjoy listening to the bass work. Its fresh. Your fills aren't designed to "show off" either. They are well-disciplined expressions that help guide each song along. I put you up there with Sir Paul McCartney in all of these respects. Every time I listen to this album I have to go play bass immediately after. Your work is inspirational.

3) Your bass lines are very creative; arguably genius. The note selection, rhythm, fills, etc., are very original and do each song a service. If you took each song from the album and asked AI to develop the perfect bass line for them, it would spit out your bass lines.

4) The "run" you do at the end of the titular song is EPIC.

5) I am not much of a tone guy, i.e. gear head, but I do enjoy your consistent natural bass tone throughout the album.

You are severely underrated, as many great bass players are. So this letter is to let you know that you are appreciated for your artistic ability, mechanics, and groove. You are a bass player's bass player. May God bless you, and may God bless the United States of America.
Why not bless Canada?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Root 5
'When I go Out With Artists' is the standout track for me,bass wise.Great album tho'.
Yes, that is a great song. You know, Crash Test Dummies are one of the most original bands. They had the low/high singers in unison, but they actually are one of the few to be successful with "comedy rock". Their lyrics are absurd, but funny, like dark humour funny. I don't know many other bands that can pull it off. Only Ween comes to mind, and of course, Zappa. Weird Al doesn't count, haha.
 
I stumbled on this thread because it's Dan's birthday today! He's been on my short-list of favorite bass players for as long as I've had a short-list.

Edit: Since I woke up the thread, I thought I'd share a couple of things. I think I've covers most of the "God Shuffled His Feet" album on my YouTube channel, but "When I Go Out With Artists" is my favorite song and has its own playlist... haha. I've gotten to meet the band a few times and came dangerously close to them allowing me to play "... Artists" with them at soundcheck but, unfortunately, it didn't work out.
Here's that Playlist and a pic with Dan at Daryl's House.

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLUWPi-F30tWjKeg3NezpspHbSOh-vA-Xs

Dan Roberts.jpeg
 
Last edited:
I stumbled on this thread because it's Dan's birthday today! He's been on my short-list of favorite bass players for as long as I've had a short-list.

View attachment 5455936

No way! This is too cool. "When I Go Out with Artists" and "Afternoons and Coffeespoons"... The feel good songs of the album. Both are great. I will check out your YT channel, sounds cool.
 
No way! This is too cool. "When I Go Out with Artists" and "Afternoons and Coffeespoons"... The feel good songs of the album. Both are great. I will check out your YT channel, sounds cool.
‘Coffeespoons’ has a great bassline too. His playing is very supportive & melodic overall.

‘Mmmm’ is one of my all-time favourite basslines. Great band