I'm putting together a PA system for my band. I already have the mains, now I need monitors (the band is not ready to go to IEMs yet). My question is, I would like to get 10" monitors to keep price down and an easier load in and out. However, it seems like most monitors are 12". Our stage volume isn't too loud. Would 10's be enough. Thanks
Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
Welcome to TalkBass! Want to remove ads? Register an account and login to see fewer ads, and become a Supporting Member to remove almost all ads.
Answer #1: yes
Answer #2: no
Answer #3: maybe
Answer #2: no
Answer #3: maybe
Depends on the monitor. I have some Yamaha dxr10s that are plenty loud. According to the spec they have a max SPL of 131 compared to 132for the 12 inch version.
Thanks, great point. I could probably get away with a quality 10" monitor vs a cheap 12".
Buy once, cry once. I'm a firm believer in the "better to have too much than not enough" philosophy.
That's fine if you're not the one that has to hump the bigger ones
.I've never had a problem with 10" monitors even when going ampless - but I know enough to HPF them and size the amp properly.
Put the monitors closer to your ears, then they are louder.
Carvin sells a PM5, and Galaxy make monitors that mount on a mic stand for nice close placement. One step closer to IEMs
Carvin sells a PM5, and Galaxy make monitors that mount on a mic stand for nice close placement. One step closer to IEMs
Pretty much what modulusman said. If the 10s are something like Yamaha DXR10s or QSC K10s then absolutely no problem as monitors. If they're Kustoms or Harbingers you're going to stuggle to hear yourselves.
I'd actually love a set of DXR10s as monitors myself. Plenty loud and extremely light.
I'd actually love a set of DXR10s as monitors myself. Plenty loud and extremely light.
This ^
I have taken that to it's logical limit and gone to IEMs after decades of struggling to hear floor monitors, no way am I ever going back. Even cheap IEMs outperform (by a large margin) any floor monitors that I have ever used.
Not for everyone I know but worth thinking about.
(IMO but YMMV of course)
Only if you are using cheap junk like Kustom.
I just returned from band practice where I used a Yamaha DXR10 for my bass amp. Plenty of low end and the volume knob was at about 9 O'clock on the speaker cab.
wmhill
Inactive
- Aug 20, 2012
- 4,054
- 17,253
- 4,841
- Disclosures
- MTD basses endorsed artist Bartolini pickups emerging artist TECAMP bass players gear endorsed
Unless you are in the quietest band imaginable, and they are super high quality monitors..... you're not gonna be happy with em.
My last band (two guitars, heavy hitting drummer) used QSC K10s as wedge monitors along front of stage. PLENTY loud. Holy crap those things rule.
The most important question is this.
What will you be running through them?
If the drummer uses one and wants kick drum in his monitor, and you use one and want bass in it, probably not for regular consumer grade stuff. If vocals and acoustic is about what you will be doing with them pretty much any mid priced 10" will he fine.
What will you be running through them?
If the drummer uses one and wants kick drum in his monitor, and you use one and want bass in it, probably not for regular consumer grade stuff. If vocals and acoustic is about what you will be doing with them pretty much any mid priced 10" will he fine.
buldog5151bass
Kibble, milkbones, and P Basses. And redheads.
Depends on:
1. What is going through them?
2. Are they good ones?
1. What is going through them?
2. Are they good ones?
We use 10" powered monitor/monitors when playing in some of the small places, only for vocals, they are 650 watts/each and plenty loud for the small places, for bigger places a set of JBL 515eons work great for us.
I think the key is your stage volumes aren't too loud.
I have both a QSC-K10, and a lighter cheaper DBR-10, once I got the DBR-10 it became my main on-stage monitor, 10 lbs lighter than the K10, and 129db spl. Buy from a store with a nice return policy, dare I say GC's 45-day return policy is fantastic.
I have both a QSC-K10, and a lighter cheaper DBR-10, once I got the DBR-10 it became my main on-stage monitor, 10 lbs lighter than the K10, and 129db spl. Buy from a store with a nice return policy, dare I say GC's 45-day return policy is fantastic.
No just have real world experience with better PA gear than you have ever used. IMO the DXR10 is the best speaker in its price range available. On pro sound web their is a thread doing a speaker shootout and the reviewers said that they were really surprised how good they were for the money. They were comparing them to speakers that cost about twice as much.
I have some EAW powered speakers that consist of a 15 and a horn. When doing a side by side comparison the DXR10 had more bass response when in FOH mode than the EAW. The EAW cost 5 times as much.
Last edited: