Dual P pickups are the best pickup configuration in existance

poochiecheeks

Supporting Member
Feb 23, 2020
560
1,450
3,261
Central New Jersey
OK hear me out. I'm rebuilding my Dean explorer bass to have a dual P setup, and in the process I realized that having two P pickups is a perfect and infallible design.

1- Can sound good with any placement between the end of the neck and the bridge
2- Always follows the radius of the fretboard for most efficient sound capture
3- Because of the split design you can always center the two strings for each coil during installation no matter where in the neck taper you put them
4- Offset split design (in non reverse setup) means higher strings receive more treble response and lower strings receive more bass response
5- 100% hum cancelling in any configuration at all times
6- Offers all the benefits of a J bass if placed in the same relative locations with none of the downsides
7- Looks absolutely stunning and bada$$
8- Fairly uncommon meaning you will always get compliments on your bass
9- Wiring to the pots acts like a humbucker but with no annoying wires you have to solder and tape together to wire the coils in series
10- Maximum area beneath the strings to use as a speed ramp short of putting in dual music mans
11- Using the neck pickup alone means you always have the P bass sound available to you without having to use a PJ
12- Relatively low pickup impedance compared to similar humbucker setups
13- Much more comfortable thumb anchor than a J pickup due to the mounting screw located at the end of each coil instead of on the top and bottom sides
14- Did I mention it looks amazing

Literally WHY does no one talk about this setup? I can't think of anything wrong with it. Just try and prove me wrong, I bet you can't.
 
I can't abide the thumb-anchoring or 'literally', but I agree that double split-coils is a layout that should be more common.
One of the best designs Fender ever had was the Blacktop Jazz:

fender-blacktop-jazz-bass-black-xl.jpg


However, out there in the wild are many many SR500 Ibanez, which use split-coil MK1 Bartolini pickups.

This dude never sounded better than on his B.C.R. with the dual split-coils:

da3dce63d3356814ff0677966fb16b6d.jpg
 
This is what it looks like now but this is a cheap Dean metalman Z that I have changed basically everything on, only the neck and body are still original. I'm routing the pickup holes now that I filled in the original soapbar humbucker hole as well as the neck pickup that I added, I also reshaped the headstock from the Dean V to a gibson banana headstock, we'll see if it doesn't snap in half once I put tuners and string tension on it
 

Attachments

  • 5E459C36-832D-4A49-A0B1-3BCD39A91C9B.jpeg
    5E459C36-832D-4A49-A0B1-3BCD39A91C9B.jpeg
    849.5 KB · Views: 509
I agree only with no. 2, that can be serious problem if you have a flat pickup and vintage (small) fretboard radius. The rest is either non-issue or subjective. But I have nothing against it, if it works for you and you like it, cool.
 
I am not a fan at all of the P style pickups, but if I found a bass that I liked everything else about it- the dual Ps would be my go-to mod.