Is it really Paul playing bass on Here Comes the Sun?

I just read this on Wikipedia, which verifies that Paul did play bass, but your thought might come from the fact that George Martin added orchestrations, including standup bass, which more than like was done by a studio musician.

"Harrison, Paul McCartney and Ringo Starr recorded the rhythm track... the orchestral parts (George Martin's score for four violas, four cellos, double bass..."

Here Comes the Sun - Wikipedia
 
Yes, as I said, the common sources on the internet all say it was Paul. What makes me ask the question is exactly that: although everybody seems to be saying Paul, it doesn’t sound like him to me. First and foremost, no pick attack. Ok, there are some pictures in which he’s playing with his thumb, but usually his sound has a more defined attack. Second, the kind of line, following the acoustic guitar groove, not many fills, doesn’t sound like him either.
 
Sounds like pickstyle to me. Likely had the treble rolled down on the bass or in the mix so there isn't as obvious an attack, but the envelope of the notes (and the attack that is there) definitely sound like pick to me as opposed to fingers or thumb. By that time he could have been playing his Ric, Hofner, or Jazz - I think it might be the Jazz....
 
Last edited:
Oh, yeah. I forgot there are some tunes where there is no electric bass. My bad...
John and George both played bass on a few here and there. Pretty sure it's one of them on "Hey Jude"--I think that's George on a Jazz(Fender sent them both right and lefty Jazz basses). John played a Bass VI, on what I can't recall right now (Helter Skelter for sure I think). I'm sure some of the Beatles experts on TB can chime in!
 
Last edited:
Old song, probably old question, but I couldn't find a satisfying answer anywhere. To me it never sounded like it was Paul, but all I could find online says that it was, so I was not satisfied and decided to ask real humans... lol

Ok, maybe it was him, but don't y'all think that the tone and even the bass line ideas were somewhat atypical for him?

Not really, stylistically I don’t hear any difference, nor do I hear and thing from a technique standpoint that would leave me to believe there was a different bass player. What I do hear is a very good bassist serving a song he didn’t create.
 
Not really, stylistically I don’t hear any difference, nor do I hear and thing from a technique standpoint that would leave me to believe there was a different bass player. What I do hear is a very good bassist serving a song he didn’t create.
And if you listen closely, you do hear the "click" in the pick attack (or at least I do!:))
 
McCartney adapted his style to fit according to each song. For example, his bass playing on his own ballad Here, There, and Everywhere is almost exclusively confined to root notes, because that's what worked best.

Here Comes The Sun isn't a ballad, but it has a number of tricky parts with highly unusual timing. Paul, I think, figured that there was enough going on in the song without adding, e.g., a bass countermelody.

His playing on George's ballad Something, on the other hand, while widely beloved by bassists who are frustrated guitarists, was arguably a rare misjudgment. Harrison, upon hearing the bass part that Paul had played, asked him to play a line as simple as the ones Paul invariably used on his own songs instead.

Paul refused to do so. Which I take to indicate that it was meant as a middle finger to George. Why? Who knows.
 
John and George both played bass on a few here and there. Pretty sure it's one of them on "Hey Jude"--I think that's George on a Jazz(Fender sent them both right and lefty Jazz basses). John played a Bass VI, on what I can't recall right now (Helter Skelter for sure I think). I'm sure some of the Beatles experts on TB can chime in!
no expert, but it's george ( jazz bass, ) on " old brown shoe. "
 
  • Like
Reactions: GregC and LowendG
1562661181_254698190372437_goldstyles.jpg
 
There are songs where John or George play bass. Others have mentioned some of those songs. Additionally, there's "Back in the USSR" (John), "The Long and Winding Road" (John), and "Maxwell's Silver Hammer" (George). There may be others.
Yeah, I had read that about "Maxwell's Silver Hammer" - that's one where you could certainly have fooled me if you said it was Paul!