I've struggled with these sorts of basses. A neck single coil or P pickup encourages one sort of playing and tends to be shunted closer to the neck so is a bit darker than a stock Fender-type bass. A MM pickup tends to have more output and a taut, compressed tone and attitude. Having both on one instrument was too confusing for me, toggling between a loud bright tone and a far less snappy, quieter and darker tone.
To me the magic often comes from blending the two pickups. I also love having the flexibility of picking different pickups for different settings. 100% neck pickup for vintage-y tones, etc.
Also, in a properly designed bass like this, the two pickups are positioned and selected to compliment eachother, so it's not really like a mix of a bass with only a neck pickup and a bass with only a bridge pickup.
Yup, use both pickups togetherTo me the magic often comes from blending the two pickups. I also love having the flexibility of picking different pickups for different settings. 100% neck pickup for vintage-y tones, etc.
Also, in a properly designed bass like this, the two pickups are positioned and selected to compliment eachother, so it's not really like a mix of a bass with only a neck pickup and a bass with only a bridge pickup.
Here are a couple of mine.View attachment 4949373
Im very impressed with it. It still has the stock humbucker and its passive. Adding the J the way I did was after testing it on another bass i have for testing pickup configurations. I can move them around in a huge cavity I routed out. I was surprised that angle for the J was the way to go (its a bridge Wilkinson that I had lying around). I thought it was going to be the other way.I'd love to hear more about the OLP with the angled jazz pickup. I've though of modding a Stingray short scale to a similar configuration, but I've never seen anything like this.