It's not a she. It's "A Boy Named Sue".What has she got to do with it?
I would probably not put it in the case again without confirming with Protec that it is nitro safe. There's always a chance that the nitro didn't cure properly but it stands to reason that the finish is mushy in that location because that is the spot that bears the most weight when it's sitting unused. I left a nitro finished bass on a synthetic blanket and the fiber pattern got "burned" into the finish in one spot.
It's not a she. It's "A Boy Named Sue".