Senior bass moment: fret buzz or my weak left hand?

JProbber

Gold Supporting Member
Jan 16, 2023
59
74
666
I've taken the bass back up after 45 years. Trying to work myself into shape, but getting noticeable E string fret buzz often. Other 3 seem alright. Is there a definitive way to tell if its the bass or my arthritis?

Thanks for any advice you can provide.

Jon
 
  • Like
Reactions: Auspuff
E is not necessarily under more tension than other strings so it may not specifically be related you your strength. However, the angle/bend at which you strike is different than a G string. It could be a physical thing that exercises/practice will resolve.

But since it’s just the one string my first move is to look at the setup. Maybe as simple as a small turn of the truss rod or a bridge saddle. Do you remember how to do basic setup? Lots of resources in TB and on the YouTubes.
 
If your other 3 strings are not buzzing, than good chance it might be the E string. Action too high for the E? Too low?

Are you laying your full finger print "meat" over the E string notes? And close to the fret?

Since you are getting back into "it", the buzzing issue might clear up as you get your "chops" back up.

Good luck.
 
It should also be mentioned that on an electric bass, some buzzing is acceptable acoustically, as long as it does not come through in the amplified sound. Also examine your right hand technique (assuming your right handed). Strike the string with your finger or pick in a movement parallel to the body of the bass. You want the string to vibrate side to side above the frets, not up and down into the frets.
 
E is not necessarily under more tension than other strings so it may not specifically be related you your strength. However, the angle/bend at which you strike is different than a G string. It could be a physical thing that exercises/practice will resolve.

But since it’s just the one string my first move is to look at the setup. Maybe as simple as a small turn of the truss rod or a bridge saddle. Do you remember how to do basic setup? Lots of resources in TB and on the YouTubes.

My next setup will be my first, but I'm going to give it a shot if needed. Thanks.
 
If your other 3 strings are not buzzing, than good chance it might be the E string. Action too high for the E? Too low?

Are you laying your full finger print "meat" over the E string notes? And close to the fret?

Since you are getting back into "it", the buzzing issue might clear up as you get your "chops" back up.

Good luck.
I hope my slowly returning hand strength (and proper fretting) resolves the issue. Thanks.
 
It should also be mentioned that on an electric bass, some buzzing is acceptable acoustically, as long as it does not come through in the amplified sound. Also examine your right hand technique (assuming your right handed). Strike the string with your finger or pick in a movement parallel to the body of the bass. You want the string to vibrate side to side above the frets, not up and down into the frets.
Thanks. I'll check that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Reedt2000
My next setup will be my first, but I'm going to give it a shot if needed. Thanks.
Worst case, you can’t break anything in a half turn. If it’s not how you like just take it to a shop. It’s not very expensive for a basic setup and if it’s just 1 string it’s not as likely the frets need work. Guessing a simple adjustment. You and the bass have been waiting a while and that happens. Good luck.
 
It may come to that.

My current bass is a new Ibanez Artcore AGB200. My original bass was a beautiful Carvin which was stolen at some point. Thanks.

Bummer about the Carvin. :( Those are such iconic basses of my youth! Carvin catalogs were essential bathroom reading material. The Artcore looks beautiful though! Good luck with it.

"Is setup necessary on a brand-new bass?" is a topic that gets debated. My personal opinion is "yes," and I always do a string-change and full setup on any bass, whether it is coming to me used or new. It gives me the same sense of satisfaction as wearing a well-tailored suit.

You are of the generation (I am guessing?) you probably have basic shop skills and know how to use hand tools. I bet you could learn how to do your own setups, no problem. If the other 3 strings are perfect, and only the E string needs adjustment, you might start by adjusting the bridge saddle height screws, to slightly raise the E string.
 
We are probably close to the same age. I have one of those hand exercise devices you squeeze. I try to squeeze it with one or two fingers at a time. My pinky is fairly weak, this helps. Plus piano hand stretching. Hold your hand out and spread your fingers as far as you can. Not pressing or pulling, just stretching. Like you are trying to palm a basketball.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Maxi Funkl
It could be technique, it could just be that the string position is problematic for your arthritis, but if it's just the E string, chances are it's string or setup related. Start there.
 
Maybe he should find a physician-musician and see if he can have his bass looked at at the same time?

My oldest student is a new bassist who is in his early 60's. I work with a lot of musicians who come to me in their 50's or later.

If he isn't experiencing problems on the other strings, it's most likely a set up issue. But I agree, there's nothing wrong with talking with a Dr. as well.

He didn't mention pain, he mentioned a buzz, which would indicate instrument.
 
I hope my slowly returning hand strength (and proper fretting) resolves the issue. Thanks.
It probably will ;). I would press down on the E as much as you can with the strongest finger you have and see if it clears up.

But I’d also not worry about it too much at this stage. Look up how to do a setup, sure, even tweak it if you think it’s off, but don’t be too worried about buzzing at this point. All my basses buzz a little and I don’t care because you can’t really hear it through an amp, and you especially can’t hear it in a mix.