Seymour Duncan Quarter pound P bass pickups vs. others

I put together a cheap parts P bass to leave at the practice space and I got a good deal on a set of Quarter Pound pickups.
I've heard mixed reviews on this pickup. Some say they are too scooped in the mids, some say they are too bassy and some say they are too trebly.
My results are they are very trebly and have a lot of mids, especially high mids. The bass response is about average. I compared them to my other bass with the Steve Harris sig pickup and the only real difference is that the Quarter pounds are brighter and have less lower mids. My other p basses have Bartolinis. One is a Classic series set and one is an older set unknown model. Again and no surprise, they are much brighter and higher output than both Barts.
I'm not getting the scooped mid characteristic that everyone seems to have.
I use D'Addario EXL165 nickles which are pretty even across the frequency spectrum.
I did notice that this model pickup is newer since the label says Seymour Duncan and the older sets say Basslines.
Did they change the sound of the pickups or is this just a case of YMMV?
 
  • Like
Reactions: zapped777
The wind is the same, the branding has changed. The QPs are a pretty divisive pickup on here...some hear a lack of true mids, and some hear a lot of bass. I just hear a really powerful pickup that sounds awesome with some overdrive.
 
The wind is the same, the branding has changed. The QPs are a pretty divisive pickup on here...some hear a lack of true mids, and some hear a lot of bass. I just hear a really powerful pickup that sounds awesome with some overdrive.

Thanks for your response! I must say I am a huge fan of Seymour Duncan pickups. I love the Steve Harris pickup and I always recommend it for a good replacement that retains vintage character but has a little more punch.
I play in a hard driving punk influenced rock band and use a little overdrive and yes the Quarter Pound sounds amazing with overdrive.