Talk me out of a hollowbody

Jun 8, 2005
296
238
4,656
64
Chatham, MA
I've been playing for 45+ years and have owned a lot of gear. I'm currently playing 2 slabs, an ABG, and an upright. The styles I play are all over the map; my last band was hard rock, metal, & originals. I'm currently doing an acoustic blues (Hot Tuna-type) thing, I jammed with classic rockers over the weekend, I'm backing up a uke band tomorrow night at a holiday show, and have an acoustic originals show Friday, among other things.

I had a somewhat unfulfilling experience with my URB yesterday. Couldn't get a good sound, wouldn't punch through, the decay on the notes is so quick I might as well be playing drums, etc. I'm thinking that as much as I like playing it, it doesn't really fit with a lot of the music I play.

My ABG (Samick AB-2) is not a professional quality instrument, and has a funky truss rod. It's tight, but still makes a clunky sound that gets set buzzing on G harmonics. Can only use the piezo pickup, if I so much as crack open the mic pickup it feeds back. And it plays like a cheap-ish acoustic guitar, and has lots of fret noise even with flatwounds.

I woke up this morning thinking alternately of a Epiphone Jack Casady model, and a Breedlove Solo Bass FL. The first most know, the second is a decent quality fretless ABG, which a local dealer says is a very good/"best" ABG for the money. OK, the lesser "Pursuit" bass gets the "for the money" comment, but they're a known maker, and it represents a price point if nothing else.

The thing is, no one is complaining about my current axes (eg, "you can't play that slab electric bass in this acoustic blues act"), though I wonder about the overall vibe presented to the audience. So I'm probably just experiencing GAS, but I've been thinking about it for a while.

I've also been thinking about picking up a passive bass, since both my slabs (Schecter, Lakland) are active. I'm a bit of a traditionalist at times, and fear ripping battery wires out at inopportune times (I've come close once or twice).

I've owned a semi-hollow bass before, a cheap Ibanez Artcore AB2, that lasted for about a year until I flipped it for something else. It wasn't a terrible guitar, but one thing that did bug me was the way the sharp edges dug into my ribs and arm when I played. Are the Casaday models any more comfortable?

So, I guess the question comes down to, what is the TB community thought on this? Believe it or not many here obsess about equipment far more than I do :), so I'm wondering, if you were in my shoes would you be looking to make a change? Should I ditch the current ABG and one of the slabs and get something nice, focus on that? The ABG is nice for grabbing quick while sitting on the couch, if nothing else.

And yes, I have thought about selling all my current gear including the URB to fund a Marleux Diva, which I think is about the sexiest thing ever, but isn't hollow nor acoustic, and is a whole different can of worms...

GAS and bass thoughts for a Monday morning.
 
I think it"s like you said it could be GAS. Nothing wrong with that and getting a new bass however! I like the Casady but if neck dive bothers you, or large bodied basses then it may not be for you. I have an acoustic bass and I don't really play it. I don't really care for it and will mostly likely sell it down the road sometime. I prefer my Kala Ubass over an acoustic by a long shot. I can get a nice uprightish sound with it with more sustain than an URB. It's easy to play and carry around too and would work great with the uke band your playing with also. But to be honest I see no reason your 2 slabs wouldn't work in those situations either.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Groove Doctor
Thanks for the responses!
... I prefer my Kala Ubass over an acoustic by a long shot. I can get a nice uprightish sound with it with more sustain than an URB. It's easy to play and carry around too and would work great with the uke band your playing with also.
Funny you should mention that. I never liked those, and thought they were ridiculously priced for what you got. A local store is having a going out of business sale, and has one marked down to $265 or so. I still don't much care for it (those strings, and the tiny neck), but recognize that it would fit a niche, and that's not a terrible price.

Then again, after a few hours I do recognize that this is just GAS pains, and will probably let it pass. I love my current basses, so might as well just happily play them. I think the "visual style" thing is just a red herring I threw myself to envision getting a new axe. I suppose I should probably have some money before I start thinking this way, too...
 
  • Like
Reactions: petrus61
I am in a new relationship with my Casady, but its taken over as my main bass in my current project. It am going for a P bass and URB sound, and the Casady just SINGS. We were messing around with some feedback last rehearsal, I found it at least as controllable as my solid bodies, but easier to initiate. And its not just me, my band mates get kinda disappointed when I don;t bring "the gold bass" :)
 
Buy new strings and maybe a new pickup for your upright. Mine has as much sustain as either of my Fenders. I do blues and roots. My Fenders are now relegated to backup status
Brand new Spirocores, with a K&K, going into a Tonebone PZ-Pre. Even playing with gain staging and EQ I was getting heavy feedback, boominess, and lack of sustain. I played with the EQ and notch filters last night and got a better overall sound and volume, but lost a lot of bottom end. Still might work in ensemble. Also the transporting angle.
 
Thanks for the responses!

Funny you should mention that. I never liked those, and thought they were ridiculously priced for what you got. A local store is having a going out of business sale, and has one marked down to $265 or so. I still don't much care for it (those strings, and the tiny neck), but recognize that it would fit a niche, and that's not a terrible price.

Then again, after a few hours I do recognize that this is just GAS pains, and will probably let it pass. I love my current basses, so might as well just happily play them. I think the "visual style" thing is just a red herring I threw myself to envision getting a new axe. I suppose I should probably have some money before I start thinking this way, too...
Just for the record if you decide later to try a Ubass, Rondo has solid and hollowbody ubass for about 150.00. They have decent reviews, and with all things Ubass I recommend the fretless versions. They are quick to get used to and don't have intonation problems. Plus you have more string options available for these mini basses than you did a couple years ago.
 
If you like a muddy sound, having to constantly fight low end feedback, prefer little definition or note clarity, and enjoy going thru the process of selling off something you're disenchanted with and taking a loss on the sale, then get a hollow body electric bass.

Which might be true assuming you don't have a clue how to play or EQ one. ;)
 
I'd go for a semi-hollowbody before I went for a full hollowbody.

Depending on your budget, a Willcox Saber VL might be something you'd like to try if you can find one. I got a crack at a fretless 4 and I fell in love. Unfortunately you could hear a booming echo in my checking account when I had a chance to buy one, so I had to pass. Stellar bass. They run about $1700.

Slightly less expensive are Guild Starfires. Another nice choice IMO.