Your opinions; overrated and underrated bass players

Goy77

Guest
Feb 28, 2017
50
35
4,571
Ohio
Recently I've been enjoying a lot of Jeff Berlin and noticed how he's completely omitted slap from his repertoire of playing tricks and it made me think.. There are so many one truck pony bass players out there.. I think Jeff, as celebrated as he might be, he's still criminally underrated. While people like Tal Wilkenfeld(did I get that right?) and flea are worshipped. I have tried to like Tal's playing but nothing I have heard from her impressed me. Feel free to change my mind but I think if she's being propped up just because she's a woman then there are actually better female bass players in THAT case (Marta Altesa anyone?).. Flea on the other hand is a miserable bass player, I'm not getting why anyone is a fan of his.. Unless it's the only slap bass they've heard in which case they need schooled on some classics. I think flea made his career ripping off the true funk and disco musicians.. Slapping and popping a few OCTAVES every now and then doesn't make you some bass God.. I seen a recent video of him live with Nile Rodgers trying to play "Le Freak" and he absolutely butchered it, really??! I also want to state that I think Leon Sylvers is a criminally underrated bass player. He always balanced nice meaty finger style playing with tasteful slapping, a real skillful player. He produced and played in Dynasty, The Whispers, Shalamar etc. I'm interested in learning about some great bass players you think are underrated and also who you think needs less attention. I'm sure Flea was a obvious one and I'm sure I know a few you'll end up mentioning but I would like to hear everyone's thoughts.

talk about a "weak" jam..
 
  • Like
Reactions: ICM
I'll look into him and get back to you. Any songs in particular that you just absolutely love?
There are so many!

The entire album of Genuine Imitation Life Gazette is amazing; especially Wall Street Village Day.
Others are: Let's Hang On, and Working my Way back to You (these two were apparently played by someone else in the interim switch between Nick Massi and Joe Long, but I strongly believe it was Long who played these. They sound just like his style. Long says that Opus 17 was the first song he remembers working on but I digress). I've Got You Under My Skin, My Eyes Adored You, and Swearing to God are other ones.
I love his approach to the instrument. He was originally a classic upright player but after a hand injury he has to switch to electric.
He played a white Hagstrom, a white Fender Jazz, and an Ampeg Scroll bass. All lefty too!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Goy77
Joe Long of The Four Seasons is extremely underrated IMO. I really love his work on bass; his lines are very ingenuitive.

I was just listening to “my eyes adored you”. What a great choice of notes and use of space! Joe plays just enough and makes it real interesting at the same time. More bass players should know about him
 
  • Like
Reactions: ICM
Really not "underrated" but not really popular in the U.S... Alain Caron, for a monster fusion player he is extremely musical/listenable. I find many in that genre kinda tedious.. His song "Trouble" is my ringtone.
 
  • Like
Reactions: India_Sierra
I agree that Leon Sylvers III is underrated, I love the bass line to the Whispers song And the Beat Goes On.

I also think that the late, great Tommy Cogbill is underrated, a session man who worked with Wilson Pickett, Aretha Franklin, Dusty Springfield, Elvis Presley and more. Some songs on his resumé:

Respect - Aretha Franklin
Funky Broadway - Wilson Pickett
Son of a Preacher Man - Dusty Springfield
In the Ghetto - Elvis Presley