I understand how {Upton} probably can’t compete with decent Chinese basses; it costs more to pay a living wage here than over there.
It's been a while since I talked with Gary Upton on these topics. What follows it my take and by no means represents the positions of any of my clients:
It's possible that the Uptons' decision to stop building laminated-top basses comes from personnel considerations more than anything else. On the one hand AFAIK everybody who's been at Upton for a while can build a bass from start to finish. On the other hand, there are particular people who are really good at particular jobs and Gary is sensitive to that as you would expect. Over the years there have been people who really thrived on being The Laminated Bass Person -- Vicky comes to mind immediately -- and there might not be somebody like that at this moment.
As far as "a US living wage," people tend to stay at Upton for a long time and I assume that reflects that they like their jobs. Part of luthiery is building expertise through experience. Part of being a respectful, supportive employer is about helping each employee to find things that they thrive on and, if advisable,
adjusting your business to allow those people to develop those aspects of their work. I've done that in my business and it's a fair guess that Gary does that in his.
I can't make a habit of posting these kinds of comments (because it's easy for people to mistake them for veiled pronouncements of my clients) but I've thought a lot about the topic over the years. I don't think that Gary dwells on how years ago people told him, "Don't do it -- you can't compete with the Eastern Europeans and the Chinese on quality or price," and the record shows that those people were wrong. But I remember that!
DISCLAIMER: I am actually proud to represent Upton Bass String Instrument Corp. as its attorney. This is not a neutral post from a neutral poster.
Again, these are my comments and do not reflect the views of any of my clients.
Sometimes the requirements of attorney-client privilege get frisky but I am so lucky to have lived this life at work for the past 30+ years.
Out!