Why is "groove" so regarded as the be-all and end-all when it comes to bass playing?
Because too many people got it in their heads that "groove" and good feel are interchangeable terms. They aren't.
Why is "groove" so regarded as the be-all and end-all when it comes to bass playing?
The Airplane didn't "groove" because they were not a "groove" band. Why is "groove" so regarded as the be-all and end-all when it comes to bass playing? Some music is not meant to groove. Some music turns into something else completely when you try to make it groove, and not always in a good way. Not all music should be funk, after all.
And...?2 quick points...
It's hard to groove when your heads swimming in the electric kool aid.
Jefferson Airplane was, apart from their singles (and even they are really quite strange), fairly deep in the weird. To the point of being somewhat inaccessible to the straights.
Look at the photo of his rig a few posts up. It's no Fender Rumble Combo. Aguilar stuff does fat big-time!I've tried for years to duplicate that tone. The closest I have come is using his Epiphone Signature Bass through a powered splitter, one lead through a Fender Bassman for the "clean" channel, the other though a volume pedal, and into into an EBS Valve Drive (overdrive) Preamp Pedal and then into a small Fender Rumble Combo for the "dirty" channel. I can get that signature "growl" in the upper registers, but this setup lacks the same responsiveness down low.
Gee.How'd you figure that out? Oh by the way, not a funk band. You're welcome.They seem utterly groove-less