New to pedals... Help me pick out a fuzz!

Which fuzz pedal would be the best fit?

  • EHX Bass Big Muff Pi

    Votes: 8 8.4%
  • Green Russian Big Muff

    Votes: 19 20.0%
  • Spaceman Nebula

    Votes: 4 4.2%
  • Magick Fuzz

    Votes: 3 3.2%
  • MXR Bass Fuzz Deluxe

    Votes: 3 3.2%
  • Aguilar Fuzzistor

    Votes: 2 2.1%
  • Zvex Woolly Mammoth

    Votes: 3 3.2%
  • Darkglass Duality

    Votes: 11 11.6%
  • JHS 4 Wheeler

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Earthquaker Erupter

    Votes: 1 1.1%
  • Other (please specify)

    Votes: 41 43.2%

  • Total voters
    95
The new ehx/sovtek Russian big muff deluxe is really really good, and it's really cheap compared to similar pedals. Bumped my green Russian reissue right off the board!
Edit: it has pretty much everything mod wise done to the big muff. Tone wicker, blend, noise gate, separate mid footswitch, mid boost and cut, along with high or low q. It's incredible what they put into that pedal for $150 the pedal is on the bigger side, but looks really cool and has the goods
 
Last edited:
Okay so a little background info: I just got into pedals about a year ago and have been constantly GAS-ing and agonizing over which ones to get ever since. I'm pretty happy with my lineup as of now...

Fender P Bass > Polytune > EHX Freeze > TC Sub n Up > Tomkat Violet Muffer > Darkglass Alpha Omicron > Tech 21 BDDI V2 > Genz Benz 3.0 and Hartke Hydrive 112

...except for the Violet Muffer. I find that the mid range is weak and gets lost behind the band, and, though this doesn't matter that much to me in the band context, it doesn't really play nice with my other pedals no matter how the signal chain is set up (sounds really messy unless on its own). I play in an indie-rock band (we've been compared to Weezer, The Shins, Lord Huron, Arcade Fire, Fleet Foxes) that rarely gets really heavy, so the fuzz is mostly for me to beef up parts of many songs, as well as provide more texture to when the bass line is more exposed. So I turn to you TB'ers. What fuzz do you think would fit in this scenario? (Budget is flexible, but I doubt I'd be willing to go over $300 for a pedal) Appreciate the help!
Off topic, but have you tried putting the SubnUp after the fuzz? cleaner sub and less overloading of the fuzz. IMO of course it's a matter of taste.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BassGeekJack
The wooly mammoth is very good. Also I recently heard a demo of the Mooer Bass Fog, which is supposed to be a Mammoth clone. Very impressive, also cheap and tiny.

I'll also second the EBS Fuzzmo. They were blowing them out at $40 not too long ago and you can still find them fairly cheaply. Very versatile fuzz.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BassGeekJack
I’m a big fan of the Spruce Old Growth Fuzz!!! Not only can it dial up outrageous fuzz, it behaves when you want it to. I’ve had many other fuzzes that are uncontrollable... just put the gain barely up and you are waaaaay past reasonable volume.

Not the Old Growth. Mind you, it can definitely push with the best of them. But it seems most of the others must use pots that have a drastic curve, while Spruce uses very well tapered electronics.

 
Oh and whichever fuzz pedal on which you decide, depending on your bass guitar, be prepared to possibly need a noise gate. I have an Ibanez Sound Gear with active pickups. When I turn the gain up to a certain point, I can really hear every finger movement. Possibly switching to flatwounds would fix the issue also, but the “noise” only exists when the gain gets to a certain level.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BassGeekJack
Aftershock Bass Distortion

+1 for the SA Aftershock you start out with three choice fuzzes to diddle and drive but dig in with the Neuro editor and the world of saturation is at your command. Six fuzzes for one spot on your board but if you are creative even more.
I recently purchased one. Lots of usable sounds in a band context. I’m using it in a Stoner/doom/sludge type band, btw. I haven’t yet dig into the editing options, but it is already worth the money.
 
I've experimented with a few, here's my quick experience

Source Audio Aftershock
This thing does it all.

Way Huge Swollen Pickle
Classic. Massive.

Zvex Mastotron
Synth Heaven, one trick pony (I can get pretty close with the aftershock)

DOD Bonecrusher
Sounds nearly identical to the swollen pickle to me, but definitely the lesser of the two.

EHX Bass big muff
My first fuzz. I wish someone told me to skip this one. Thin and yucky.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BassGeekJack
Wouldn’t that have a negative impact on tracking with the octaver?
No, because the SubnUp is polyphonic. Another advantage to fuzz-first is that the octaver benefits from the sustain of the fuzz; otherwise the octaver will drop out early on extended notes.
I actually find monophonic subs (like Meatbox) to work better this way as well. So long as you are not trying to play chords (which don't work well even without fuzz), it's all good. The harmonic content from the fuzz doesn't seem to cause a problem with tracking.