For anyone who is interested in hearing these basses playing a few different basslines. And polls are always fun!
Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
Welcome to TalkBass! Want to remove ads? Register an account and login to see fewer ads, and become a Supporting Member to remove almost all ads.
Stingray Special vs. Yamaha BBP34 video
- Thread starter Vanheusen77
- Start date
I’ll always prefer the StingRay , but I must admit the Yamaha BB always sound good, just different .
I always will prefer a Stingray slap or pluck tone over a PJ, but that Yamaha sounds fine slapped or plucked and the finger or pick tones are even to my ears.
I think the Yamaha BB really shines with pick play.
To me, the Stingray sounded Ok for the slap but both Yamaha options sounded far more musical for everything else.
I voted for the StingRay, but surprisingly I liked the sound of the Yamaha with both pickups, and I typically don't like PJs. Both are good-sounding basses!
Last edited:
I thought @Vanheusen77 sounded very good, again, in this video.
If you play the Yamaha in context where having a P-style pickup makes a difference, then the Ray will loose.
However, try to play some of the Chic’s classics with a P (some of them were actually recorded using a P however) and you’ll discover where the Ray wins.
There’s no winner here .. carrots for me but this option is not available ..
Altitude
An ounce of perception, a pound of obscure.
That video mostly proves that it doesn't matter. OP's playing is rock solid and both basses sound good.
The bass that makes you want to pick it up and practice more is the right one.
The bass that makes you want to pick it up and practice more is the right one.
BobDeRosa
Commercial User
- May 16, 2012
- 2,377
- 4,287
- 5,316
- Disclosures
- Owner, Tritone Jazz Fantasy Camps
Interesting because I voted for the BBP with both pickups, but I never use the J pickup on my own. The StingRay is a fine sounding instrument, but I like more control than it offers.
Bonus points for including a pick and limiting the slap 
all those sounds have their places but overall I liked the P+J fingerstyle best.
all those sounds have their places but overall I liked the P+J fingerstyle best.
How do you define control? When it comes to tone shaping, The two or three band eq provides lots of options.
Great video! Those BB sounds really good well balanced PJ tone
As far as PJ tone goes, the YAMAHA is one of the best sounding ones I've heard. The Ray sounds like well, a Ray and it sits so nice in the mix. I really like them both.
