Hi mbart203! I went through the same thing three years ago, I first try out the Daddario Halfs and the were more like flats than rounds felling wise, and they still kept the brightness of the rounds for some time. Then I try out the Ghs Brite Flats, which was like a step backwards for me, beacause they are more similar to rounds than the Daddario halfs, feeling more rough on the fingers, even though I prefer the sound of the Brite flats.
So for me, if you objetive is to reduce your fingers and be easier on you fingers, Daddario Halfs all day long. But, if you want to preserve some of the brighter tone of the rounds, Ghs Brite flats.