When an artist scoring a hit with a cover goes haywire, the story of "Hot-hot-hot"

Nov 27, 2003
1,994
5,198
5,451
48
The Netherlands
Disclosures
Rogue luthier employed at Knooren Handcrafted bass guitars
Success, it’s fickle and depends on a lot of hard work and an even bigger dose of sheer luck to become a legend. Still, you can’t knock it, why complain when you achieved what you set out to do?

But a lot of times, artists end up hating the song that made them big, or to put it more eloquently: they hate what that song became. As people knew them for THAT song and ONLY that song and the other songs were irrelevant to the fans. To such a degree that they’d walk out of the venue after that said song was played. Some bands resorting to NOT playing their biggest hit, making it that the audience HAD to listen to the other material. Such as Nirvana did with “Smells like Teen Spirit” and Radiohead with “Creep”

But now imagine scoring that hit-you-can’t-get-away-from with a song that you didn’t even write.

So I figured it to be fun to talk about those times where artists scored their biggest hit with a COVER and never got away from that one.

BcLAjtVn_400x400.jpg

This is David Johansen, of the New York Dolls, who in the mid-eighties had a brainwave. With so many hair metal bands which aped the New York Dolls' style, it was time for him to change. Johansen started donning a three-piece suit, styled his hair into a Pompadour, and adopted a more suitable name for his career change. Buster Poindexter was born.

images

And he already had a song in mind with which he planned to launch Buster Poindexter into the world. A song he first encountered while on Holiday in Montserrat. A song, he was told, had been on the number one spot in the charts for TWO consecutive years.


So, recognizing a hit when he heard one, Johansen went into the studio and recorded “Hot-hot-hot” and it indeed gave him the hit he thought it was when hearing the original. The music video was also memorable in showing Buster Poindexter talking about the New York Dolls and the “Outrageous clothes he wore back then.” Sadly, that music video is no longer on Youtube.


But the song had been number one on the charts in Montserrat for two years for a very good reason, much like the title suggested, it was like an ongoing inferno and became too big for Johansen to contain. He was flown all over the world to appear in chart shows, where it was a prerequisite that he’d perform “Hot-hot-hot”



And then he found out that the song became a staple at weddings and Karaoke parties, and he was getting tired of it.

These days Johansen still performs as Buster Poindexter and he also still performs that song, realizing that personal issues aside, it still is that song that made him big, and as I said before, you can’t knock it if you find success.
 
I still prefer his version of a different cover, "Build Me Up, Buttercup". Raw, unfiltered, and a better song, plain and simple.



I always dug the Dolls for being punk progenitors, but aside from the two or three obscure covers they did, I think the material was group written, or mainly by Sylvain. David solo had to rely on others writing, with him maybe doing lyrics. Besides “Frenchette”, which was more of a cult hit, he scored on radio in his rock band phase with a medley of Animals songs…


If he got burned out on “Hot Hot Hot”, that period didn’t go on forever, then(with Morrissey’s help)the Dolls reformed right before Killer Kane died from cancer. I don’t know the status with Sylvain and Nolan gone as well.
 
“Some of you older kids may remember this. About 15 years ago, as a matter of fact, I was in a band called The New York Dolls. Now look at some of these outfits. Now we used to wear some really outrageous clothes. You know, these heavy menthol bands in LA have the market cornered on wearing their mothers’ clothes.

So now I come into this refined and dignified kind of a situation. I’m playing music that’s so soft and sweet. I mean, you can sit by the fireplace and listen to it. You can have a little… glass of wine maybe, or you can even have dinner with this music. Come on, I'll show you..."
- Buster Poindexter / David Johansen, 1987

 
Last edited:
“Some of you older kids may remember this. About 15 years ago, as a matter of fact, I was in a band called The New York Dolls. Now look at some of these outfits. Now we used to wear some really outrageous clothes. You know, these heavy menthol bands in LA have the market cornered on wearing their mothers’ clothes.

So now I come into this refined and dignified kind of situation. I’m playing music that’s so soft and sweet. I mean, you can sit by the fireplace and listen to it. You can have a little… glass of wine maybe, or you can even have dinner with it.”
- Buster Poindexter / David Johansen, 1987


Yup, and back then that monologue was my introduction to the New York dolls. Although it took some time until I actually heard their music.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MrAB4003
His solo record


41AsYFHPUsL.jpg


is a pretty fantastic rock record. Post-Dolls, pre-Buster. He did killer live shows around this time, too.

I also saw him do the Buster cabaret with a roomful of people who knew nothing about the NY Dolls and only wanted to heat Hot Hot Hot.

And not fer nuthin, but...that Arrow record is one GREAT soca record.
Yeah, he's VERY underrated as both a singer and showman. He has a GREAT rock voice, easily rivalling contemporaries such as Steven Tyler and David Lee Roth.
 
I think part of what you’re missing here is that Buster Poindexter is toungue-in-cheek. David Johansen is a great rock vocalist and a great performer but he’s also very, very funny. Buster Poindexter was a way to step outside himself and do something ridiculous and fun. It was (still is, I guess) a party band loaded with top-notch players. If he really hated playing Hot, Hot, Hot he would just stop. He’s had a pretty successful career.
 
I saw David in 1979 or 80 and it was one of my favorite shows of all time. He didn’t do a lot of Dolls stuff but he did the important ones. I always thought his solo stuff was great. Apparently not enough of us felt that way.

Anyway, you mentioned Syl, who died in 2021. That may explain why you couldn’t find him. So now David is the last Doll standing.
 
“Some of you older kids may remember this. About 15 years ago, as a matter of fact, I was in a band called The New York Dolls. Now look at some of these outfits. Now we used to wear some really outrageous clothes. You know, these heavy menthol bands in LA have the market cornered on wearing their mothers’ clothes.

So now I come into this refined and dignified kind of a situation. I’m playing music that’s so soft and sweet. I mean, you can sit by the fireplace and listen to it. You can have a little… glass of wine maybe, or you can even have dinner with this music. Come on, I'll show you..."
- Buster Poindexter / David Johansen, 1987


My first time hearing this song was on one of the Mickey's Fun Songs VHS tapes as a toddler in the late 1990s. I remember the kids and all the Disney characters were at Blizzard Beach in Disney World when it first opened. They made Blizzard Beach seem like the coolest place ever (no pun intended)!

I had no idea that Buster Poindexter / David Johansen made this song famous until I was a teenager. Today I learned how much he doesn't like performing it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DJ Bebop
Sticking with the island theme, there's the story of "Who Let The Dogs Out":



There's also "Red Red Wine". Written and originally recorded by Neil Diamond, the version most people are familiar with is the UB40 hit. What's funny is that when UB40 decided to cover the song they apprently had no knowledge of its connection to Diamond. They were, in fact, covering a cover of the original (that cover being the one by Jamaican singer Tony Tribe).

 
If the kids at my high school were already wondering about my Alice Cooper fixation, my weirdo factor went factor 10 when I bought the Dolls album as soon as it came out.
Also bought the second album, Too much too soon, out of a cut out rack about a year later.
Two great producers, Todd Rundgren and Shadow Morton!
50 years on....still a weirdo 🤪
 
Success, it’s fickle and depends on a lot of hard work and an even bigger dose of sheer luck to become a legend. Still, you can’t knock it, why complain when you achieved what you set out to do?

But a lot of times, artists end up hating the song that made them big, or to put it more eloquently: they hate what that song became. As people knew them for THAT song and ONLY that song and the other songs were irrelevant to the fans. To such a degree that they’d walk out of the venue after that said song was played. Some bands resorting to NOT playing their biggest hit, making it that the audience HAD to listen to the other material. Such as Nirvana did with “Smells like Teen Spirit” and Radiohead with “Creep”

But now imagine scoring that hit-you-can’t-get-away-from with a song that you didn’t even write.

So I figured it to be fun to talk about those times where artists scored their biggest hit with a COVER and never got away from that one.

BcLAjtVn_400x400.jpg

This is David Johansen, of the New York Dolls, who in the mid-eighties had a brainwave. With so many hair metal bands which aped the New York Dolls' style, it was time for him to change. Johansen started donning a three-piece suit, styled his hair into a Pompadour, and adopted a more suitable name for his career change. Buster Poindexter was born.

images

And he already had a song in mind with which he planned to launch Buster Poindexter into the world. A song he first encountered while on Holiday in Montserrat. A song, he was told, had been on the number one spot in the charts for TWO consecutive years.


So, recognizing a hit when he heard one, Johansen went into the studio and recorded “Hot-hot-hot” and it indeed gave him the hit he thought it was when hearing the original. The music video was also memorable in showing Buster Poindexter talking about the New York Dolls and the “Outrageous clothes he wore back then.” Sadly, that music video is no longer on Youtube.


But the song had been number one on the charts in Montserrat for two years for a very good reason, much like the title suggested, it was like an ongoing inferno and became too big for Johansen to contain. He was flown all over the world to appear in chart shows, where it was a prerequisite that he’d perform “Hot-hot-hot”



And then he found out that the song became a staple at weddings and Karaoke parties, and he was getting tired of it.

These days Johansen still performs as Buster Poindexter and he also still performs that song, realizing that personal issues aside, it still is that song that made him big, and as I said before, you can’t knock it if you find success.




My mind is too blown to contribute to this thread ; I just don't understand how I never connected David Johansen and Buster Poindexter as the same person.

I'm beginning to fear that The Mandela Effect is a real thing....