I broke the Golden Rule....

Hello Folks.

I broke the Golden Rule, and unwittingly joined a band where the vocalist / lead guitarist's wife was also in the band. It was a 5-piece;
  1. drums (nice guy to work with)
  2. bass (me)
  3. rhythm/ lead guitar (also a very nice guy to work with)
  4. lead vox / lead / rhythm guitar (nice guy to work with - most of the time) - BL
  5. backing vox / backing rhythm guitar (married to lead vox (4.) above).... and that's where the trouble starts. BL's wife.
It was all fine during rehearsals, it's a grunge covers band doing Stone Temple Pilots, Nirvana, AIC and the like (all good tunes - more popular than you'd think); however once we started "dress" rehearsals towards actual gigs things started to unravel a bit.
Backing vox (5.) never helped with loading / unloading, any set-up or tear-down (important to note for later) and was always keen to share opinion - and talk down anyone else's opinion. There was a lot of "fannying" between songs once we started gigging. (1., 2., 3. would often share a look and an eye-roll on stage while waiting for them to be ready to start the next tune.
And it was clear that (5.) never practiced guitar. Audience feedback sometimes said "why is she there?" or "what does she bring to it?" (never to her, of course, or the BL).
And sound-checks were a nightmare that often looked like a domestic while (1.) and (2.) tried to get their PA mixer set-up via the iPad (it's a Behringer XR18 - not massively complex, with on-stage amps and IEMs - at their request). No help was ever accepted - even though it was constantly offered. Made the rest of us uncomfortable. As an average, soundchecks took an hour because of this.
While the rest of us enjoyed the tunes, and the gigs (once sound-check was over), it was never allowed to point anything out to make the situation better. Always met with "I disagree" or "we disagree".

And then (5.) started arriving late for rehearsals and leaving early due to a new pet in the house.... and nothing said against this by anyone (we all know pets are as important as family, and a good respite from the daily grind). Didn't change the set-up and tear-down (or loading their van) for the rest of us, as she never helped anyway.

Anyhow... (3.) left due to a house move (different county, so unfeasible to continue - I can't say he would have left anyway, but I think it was close).

And (3.) was replaced with a friend of mine (new 3.) on rhythm guitar. For his first gig, he initially couldn't make it due to prior commitments.... we knew this so it was fine. We planned to do the gig as a 4-piece and swapped some tunes out for simpler ones. At the last minute he arrived and played the gig, as things had changed and he managed to rearrange at home. He arrived while we were setting up; a nice surprise for us, you'd think... The gig went well.

For (new 3.)'s second gig, he told us the day before that he'd be half an hour late arriving at the gig due to family stuff... and that's when it all kicked off. (1.) sent some messages on the WhatsApp group about "can't expect someone to just drop an amp and play, and think that's enough" (which clearly wasn't the case - it was half an hour, I'd said I was happy lifting his share of kit out the van, and with set-up and soundcheck taking well over an hour and a half, we could easily soak that up. And it was only his second gig). Things got a bit personal, and (new 3.) felt uncomfortable (as did I, I felt he was unfairly treated there) and he didn't feel he could do the gig - so phoned (1.) who talked him down and persuaded him to do the gig. As usual (5.) did diddly squat to help, and just spent the set-up and tear-down time drinking and talking at the bar (as was the norm at gigs). However, the actual gig went well.

(new 3.) quit the band the next day via the WhatsApp group. I was expecting this, as he's a good friend, and we had spoken before and after the gig at length.

(5.) then sent messages to the WhatApp group explaining about how being in a band meant everyone "doing their share" and that it was a "commitment" and that "we say family life comes first, but...." (the "but" therefore means it doesn't, in my view!). The hypocrisy in that put everything into perspective for me.
It was a case of "everyone else has to put an effort in, but I don't" from (5.). I'd thought this for a while, but this was the last straw. I felt like "I'm married to the Band Leader, so it's my band" meant she assumed she could do whatever she wanted, and the rest of us had to put all the effort in.

So I quit.

I felt bad for doing it, as we had done some really good gigs. We weren't paid well (fuel money at best, didn't cover the IEM kit we all bought).

Anyhow. I'm not looking for sympathy - I have my next project "in the bag" (orchestra pit for a local charitable thing - scout's gang-show) so I'll get my fix learning a load of new tunes with new people.

It's my warning to you.... never work with a couple, married or not. You'll probably work unfairly harder than one of them (and that one of them will be let off - always), and you'll never be allowed to share (or have) an opinion that differs from theirs.

It's the Golden Rule.
 
Hello Folks.

I broke the Golden Rule, and unwittingly joined a band where the vocalist / lead guitarist's wife was also in the band. It was a 5-piece;
  1. drums (nice guy to work with)
  2. bass (me)
  3. rhythm/ lead guitar (also a very nice guy to work with)
  4. lead vox / lead / rhythm guitar (nice guy to work with - most of the time) - BL
  5. backing vox / backing rhythm guitar (married to lead vox (4.) above).... and that's where the trouble starts. BL's wife.
It was all fine during rehearsals, it's a grunge covers band doing Stone Temple Pilots, Nirvana, AIC and the like (all good tunes - more popular than you'd think); however once we started "dress" rehearsals towards actual gigs things started to unravel a bit.
Backing vox (5.) never helped with loading / unloading, any set-up or tear-down (important to note for later) and was always keen to share opinion - and talk down anyone else's opinion. There was a lot of "fannying" between songs once we started gigging. (1., 2., 3. would often share a look and an eye-roll on stage while waiting for them to be ready to start the next tune.
And it was clear that (5.) never practiced guitar. Audience feedback sometimes said "why is she there?" or "what does she bring to it?" (never to her, of course, or the BL).
And sound-checks were a nightmare that often looked like a domestic while (1.) and (2.) tried to get their PA mixer set-up via the iPad (it's a Behringer XR18 - not massively complex, with on-stage amps and IEMs - at their request). No help was ever accepted - even though it was constantly offered. Made the rest of us uncomfortable. As an average, soundchecks took an hour because of this.
While the rest of us enjoyed the tunes, and the gigs (once sound-check was over), it was never allowed to point anything out to make the situation better. Always met with "I disagree" or "we disagree".

And then (5.) started arriving late for rehearsals and leaving early due to a new pet in the house.... and nothing said against this by anyone (we all know pets are as important as family, and a good respite from the daily grind). Didn't change the set-up and tear-down (or loading their van) for the rest of us, as she never helped anyway.

Anyhow... (3.) left due to a house move (different county, so unfeasible to continue - I can't say he would have left anyway, but I think it was close).

And (3.) was replaced with a friend of mine (new 3.) on rhythm guitar. For his first gig, he initially couldn't make it due to prior commitments.... we knew this so it was fine. We planned to do the gig as a 4-piece and swapped some tunes out for simpler ones. At the last minute he arrived and played the gig, as things had changed and he managed to rearrange at home. He arrived while we were setting up; a nice surprise for us, you'd think... The gig went well.

For (new 3.)'s second gig, he told us the day before that he'd be half an hour late arriving at the gig due to family stuff... and that's when it all kicked off. (1.) sent some messages on the WhatsApp group about "can't expect someone to just drop an amp and play, and think that's enough" (which clearly wasn't the case - it was half an hour, I'd said I was happy lifting his share of kit out the van, and with set-up and soundcheck taking well over an hour and a half, we could easily soak that up. And it was only his second gig). Things got a bit personal, and (new 3.) felt uncomfortable (as did I, I felt he was unfairly treated there) and he didn't feel he could do the gig - so phoned (1.) who talked him down and persuaded him to do the gig. As usual (5.) did diddly squat to help, and just spent the set-up and tear-down time drinking and talking at the bar (as was the norm at gigs). However, the actual gig went well.

(new 3.) quit the band the next day via the WhatsApp group. I was expecting this, as he's a good friend, and we had spoken before and after the gig at length.

(5.) then sent messages to the WhatApp group explaining about how being in a band meant everyone "doing their share" and that it was a "commitment" and that "we say family life comes first, but...." (the "but" therefore means it doesn't, in my view!). The hypocrisy in that put everything into perspective for me.
It was a case of "everyone else has to put an effort in, but I don't" from (5.). I'd thought this for a while, but this was the last straw. I felt like "I'm married to the Band Leader, so it's my band" meant she assumed she could do whatever she wanted, and the rest of us had to put all the effort in.

So I quit.

I felt bad for doing it, as we had done some really good gigs. We weren't paid well (fuel money at best, didn't cover the IEM kit we all bought).

Anyhow. I'm not looking for sympathy - I have my next project "in the bag" (orchestra pit for a local charitable thing - scout's gang-show) so I'll get my fix learning a load of new tunes with new people.

It's my warning to you.... never work with a couple, married or not. You'll probably work unfairly harder than one of them (and that one of them will be let off - always), and you'll never be allowed to share (or have) an opinion that differs from theirs.

It's the Golden Rule.
Sorry to hear it was such a mess for you. Sounds like you fell in with a bunch of unprofessional compadres. Married couples in groups aren't always a bad thing. Back in the early 70's I toured with a nightclub group playing 5-nights a week, 50-weeks a year, for three years. We typically played each venue for 2-weeks before packing up and driving to the next venue. The drummer and female vocalist were married. The Drummer was the Band Leader and the female vocalist was the eye candy with the great voice.

We were paid well and our price went up each time we came back because we brought so much business in. Played throughout the West Coast, West, Mountain, and Mid-West states. Even after three years, we were all still good friends. We had our share of turnovers in personnel over the years going from a 4pc. to a 5pc. to a 6pc. and then back to a 5pc. again. The last year my split was the equivalent of just under $5,000 a week in 2024 dollars.

As I mentioned above, the money was good; I was young; we played a wide variety of music because we had 4 lead vocalists most of the time; and we played all different genres of music. We also only had to tear down and set back up every two weeks which makes playing gigs soooooo much easier and more enjoyable. I'd finish for the night, take my bass and my mic and head to the motel/hotel room. I had a really great time over those 3-years and got to know the neck on my '65 Jazz real well too with about 750 performances during that time.

So the Golden Rule isn't really cast in stone.

Here we are with our 70's finest gigging garb in 1972.
DanAndBand_800x530.jpg
 
For me, its simple, you either pull your weight and it adds up to a tangible contribution or you dont.
When the question is why are you here and it gets louder you just decide to either suck up or quit.
Trying to retrain people only works if they are on board.
From the OP, I'd be gone.

We actually have a diva...we joke about it and she doesn't agree, but if she turns up dressed up, we cut her some slack because of everything else she brings. She pretty much makes the band.
But someones partner spells trouble. Not saying its always like that...but they are either worth their place or they are not..whoever it is.
 
For me, its simple, you either pull your weight and it adds up to a tangible contribution or you dont.
When the question is why are you here and it gets louder you just decide to either suck up or quit.
Trying to retrain people only works if they are on board.
From the OP, I'd be gone.

We actually have a diva...we joke about it and she doesn't agree, but if she turns up dressed up, we cut her some slack because of everything else she brings. She pretty much makes the band.
But someones partner spells trouble. Not saying its always like that...but they are either worth their place or they are not..whoever it is.
It was exactly this - and it's the reason why I'm now gone from that band.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DJ Bebop and pepj
Sorry to hear it was such a mess for you. Sounds like you fell in with a bunch of unprofessional compadres. Married couples in groups aren't always a bad thing. Back in the early 70's I toured with a nightclub group playing 5-nights a week, 50-weeks a year, for three years. We typically played each venue for 2-weeks before packing up and driving to the next venue. The drummer and female vocalist were married. The Drummer was the Band Leader and the female vocalist was the eye candy with the great voice.

We were paid well and our price went up each time we came back because we brought so much business in. Played throughout the West Coast, West, Mountain, and Mid-West states. Even after three years, we were all still good friends. We had our share of turnovers in personnel over the years going from a 4pc. to a 5pc. to a 6pc. and then back to a 5pc. again. The last year my split was the equivalent of just under $5,000 a week in 2024 dollars.

As I mentioned above, the money was good; I was young; we played a wide variety of music because we had 4 lead vocalists most of the time; and we played all different genres of music. We also only had to tear down and set back up every two weeks which makes playing gigs soooooo much easier and more enjoyable. I'd finish for the night, take my bass and my mic and head to the motel/hotel room. I had a really great time over those 3-years and got to know the neck on my '65 Jazz real well too with about 750 performances during that time.

So the Golden Rule isn't really cast in stone.

Here we are with our 70's finest gigging garb in 1972.
View attachment 7085259
Sounds like you had a really good time with that band! Definitely a more professional outfit than the one I was in!

You're right about the Golden Rule, it's not cast in stone. But I fear it's more prevalent than anyone would like it to be.
 
Been there... When I was a kid of about 19 I was put in the position of second in command, (not by choice) and the female lead made a play for me I think more as a method of getting her influence. We dated. Eventually she decided she wasn't going to haul gear after the show. The BL asked me to convince her otherwiise ... I said if she didn't want to haul gear we should fire her and told the BL I'd be happy to tell her. She refused so I fired her, and asked if we were still going out the next day.
She mumbled something and left..... Funny... I never saw her again and it took about a week to get her replacement.
 
This can and does happen all of the time.......and I'm here to tell you that it doesn't require the presence of a married couple.

That said, ANY dysfunctional relationship in a band (a married couple with an unhealthy relationship, feuding friends, etc) will cause all kinds of issues in a band.
+1

My wife is the lead vocalist of my main band, and she/we bring no nonsense—for 13 years and counting. She has become a significant attraction for us with her stage presence and vocal ability, and the rest of us are grateful because every successful band must have that. Moreover, relations between the other players are friendly and professional. Nobody is off in the weeds nursing an attitude or destructive habits (and if that were the case, a number of highly qualified players would enjoy the opportunity). And, believe me, I waited my whole life for a situation like this.

However, I have experienced that of which the OP speaks, and it is excruciating to deal with. A project that has no stability or collective, coherent vision is like opening your kitchen pantry and finding different ingredients every time: Sometimes you get lucky with the meal, but most of the time you keenly miss what you’re lacking.

Godspeed. Life is too short to put up with projects with poor chemistry.
 
Hello Folks.

I broke the Golden Rule, and unwittingly joined a band where the vocalist / lead guitarist's wife was also in the band. It was a 5-piece;
  1. drums (nice guy to work with)
  2. bass (me)
  3. rhythm/ lead guitar (also a very nice guy to work with)
  4. lead vox / lead / rhythm guitar (nice guy to work with - most of the time) - BL
  5. backing vox / backing rhythm guitar (married to lead vox (4.) above).... and that's where the trouble starts. BL's wife.
It was all fine during rehearsals, it's a grunge covers band doing Stone Temple Pilots, Nirvana, AIC and the like (all good tunes - more popular than you'd think); however once we started "dress" rehearsals towards actual gigs things started to unravel a bit.
Backing vox (5.) never helped with loading / unloading, any set-up or tear-down (important to note for later) and was always keen to share opinion - and talk down anyone else's opinion. There was a lot of "fannying" between songs once we started gigging. (1., 2., 3. would often share a look and an eye-roll on stage while waiting for them to be ready to start the next tune.
And it was clear that (5.) never practiced guitar. Audience feedback sometimes said "why is she there?" or "what does she bring to it?" (never to her, of course, or the BL).
And sound-checks were a nightmare that often looked like a domestic while (1.) and (2.) tried to get their PA mixer set-up via the iPad (it's a Behringer XR18 - not massively complex, with on-stage amps and IEMs - at their request). No help was ever accepted - even though it was constantly offered. Made the rest of us uncomfortable. As an average, soundchecks took an hour because of this.
While the rest of us enjoyed the tunes, and the gigs (once sound-check was over), it was never allowed to point anything out to make the situation better. Always met with "I disagree" or "we disagree".

And then (5.) started arriving late for rehearsals and leaving early due to a new pet in the house.... and nothing said against this by anyone (we all know pets are as important as family, and a good respite from the daily grind). Didn't change the set-up and tear-down (or loading their van) for the rest of us, as she never helped anyway.

Anyhow... (3.) left due to a house move (different county, so unfeasible to continue - I can't say he would have left anyway, but I think it was close).

And (3.) was replaced with a friend of mine (new 3.) on rhythm guitar. For his first gig, he initially couldn't make it due to prior commitments.... we knew this so it was fine. We planned to do the gig as a 4-piece and swapped some tunes out for simpler ones. At the last minute he arrived and played the gig, as things had changed and he managed to rearrange at home. He arrived while we were setting up; a nice surprise for us, you'd think... The gig went well.

For (new 3.)'s second gig, he told us the day before that he'd be half an hour late arriving at the gig due to family stuff... and that's when it all kicked off. (1.) sent some messages on the WhatsApp group about "can't expect someone to just drop an amp and play, and think that's enough" (which clearly wasn't the case - it was half an hour, I'd said I was happy lifting his share of kit out the van, and with set-up and soundcheck taking well over an hour and a half, we could easily soak that up. And it was only his second gig). Things got a bit personal, and (new 3.) felt uncomfortable (as did I, I felt he was unfairly treated there) and he didn't feel he could do the gig - so phoned (1.) who talked him down and persuaded him to do the gig. As usual (5.) did diddly squat to help, and just spent the set-up and tear-down time drinking and talking at the bar (as was the norm at gigs). However, the actual gig went well.

(new 3.) quit the band the next day via the WhatsApp group. I was expecting this, as he's a good friend, and we had spoken before and after the gig at length.

(5.) then sent messages to the WhatApp group explaining about how being in a band meant everyone "doing their share" and that it was a "commitment" and that "we say family life comes first, but...." (the "but" therefore means it doesn't, in my view!). The hypocrisy in that put everything into perspective for me.
It was a case of "everyone else has to put an effort in, but I don't" from (5.). I'd thought this for a while, but this was the last straw. I felt like "I'm married to the Band Leader, so it's my band" meant she assumed she could do whatever she wanted, and the rest of us had to put all the effort in.

So I quit.

I felt bad for doing it, as we had done some really good gigs. We weren't paid well (fuel money at best, didn't cover the IEM kit we all bought).

Anyhow. I'm not looking for sympathy - I have my next project "in the bag" (orchestra pit for a local charitable thing - scout's gang-show) so I'll get my fix learning a load of new tunes with new people.

It's my warning to you.... never work with a couple, married or not. You'll probably work unfairly harder than one of them (and that one of them will be let off - always), and you'll never be allowed to share (or have) an opinion that differs from theirs.

It's the Golden Rule.
Played in a band with a couple. Husband on guitar, wife on vocals. Wife had just gotten a set of implants and would parade around in tops that were very revealing. Unfortunately the job that was done was not very good. This was the early days of this sort of thing and had apparently not been perfected yet 😐

Anyway she would asked the band members what we thought of these things, in front of her husband. He indicated to the band in private that he wanted us to not look at her “like that.”
So this went on for a while, she would continue to ask us and the husband would shoot us a look so we’d kinda ignore her. Out of her earshot he would criticize us for “looking” at her. Again it was not pleasant to look at, even if one was in to that.

So one practice we were playing along and she out of the blue takes her top off and again asks us what we thought of them now. Husband starts yelling at the band like we made her do this and we were enjoying this. I looked at the drummer and second guitar, they looked at me and all at once, we gathered up our stuff and left.

He called us later and tried to apologize. I told him if it makes you go crazy with us just in the room with her, what are your
going to do with a whole bar of random dudes staring at her, you going to jump off the stage and go after them?
The problem wasn't between her and us but between her and you.

It was the weirdest couples band I had ever been in, for a minute 😐

However I was in another couples band that the wife would help setup and breakdown and also made the lazy girlfriends help too! I loved that! 😍
 
Last edited:
I followed the no-relationship in the band rule, but it worked against one act when the rhythm guitarist confessed they had a crush on me (crazy, I know). I had never considered them in that regard (see rule) and maybe was in error in saying that I thought of her as a ‘younger sister.’ I thought that might express my platonic connection to her. Didn’t work. Downhill very slowly from there. 😢
 
I have broken that rule and it has worked out just fine for me.

The current band I play with started out with two married couples in the group. Drummer and his wife (she was lead vocals) and the keyboard player and his wife (she did backup vocals and lead on a couple of songs). The difference here is that NONE of us like drama. The only drama that has cropped up is when the lead vocalist was diagnosed with cancer and had to step out...taking her husband with her (so that they could gear up for the fight ahead). Keyboard player brought in his sister to replace her. We found a great drummer to succeed her husband. No drama in the new lineup, yet, but it is looking good so far. I think the key is finding people without egos to play with. I know that is extremely difficult!! Musician's tend to have egos...except most bass players. We are a humble and chill lot. :smug: :cool:
 
It's even trying sometimes to play with friends. Playing with a "couple", no way in hell, never! Sounds to me like the problem was a gutless BL if you want to call him that. #5 would have got the boot altogether. You wanna BS, do it on your time not the bands time. Work first. This wasn't a band, it was a cluster from the git go.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DJ Bebop
Well I will agree with you on this one. Been there done that also, never again. Also (not always but) working with a female in the band is also very tough to do. And of course a no way for me. (bad taste in mouth with 1/2 the band wanting to date her...lol)
It is good that you were able to move on and have other work lined up. Good luck in your new endeavor.
BTW, do the H & W team looking for other members again to continue and did you explain your issues with them so they know?
 
  • Like
Reactions: DJ Bebop