Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
Welcome to TalkBass! Want to remove ads? Register an account and login to see fewer ads, and become a Supporting Member to remove almost all ads.
I’m seeing a lot of these types of replies lately: the obligatory “don’t ask the internet response (on the internet)”
I was happy to offer my opinion, it’s what I like about social internet groups
Sure, OK, that's great. But the guy is asking for recommendations on what bass to buy based on the type of music he plays. Literally ANY bass will work for the type of music he plays. Some may work better than others, but don't you think it makes a lot more sense for the OP to oh, I don't know, go TRY OUT some of those basses on his short list and then make a decision based on which one he liked best?
This ain't rocket science folks.
Asking opinions is fine as well as checking out hours of YouTube footage to get a general idea of what you think you want but the OP should definitely try these perspective bass. In addition to a huge variety of tones the models in the poll represent a wide variety of neck designs and playing quirks. Going from a squier jazz bass to a mid-2000s Warwick or a Ric can be jarring. Best to get your hands on them before committing to buy.
What gave you the impression that the OP hasn’t tried out the basses listed? He stated the genres he plays, and stated that he is having trouble making a decision. So what bass do you recommend to help him make a decision?
I think the Elite P/J would work awesome for him.
You’re right it doesn’t take a rocket scientist to make a helpful contributive response to the OP’s questions. Great point, I agree!
I voted P bass.
You can't go wrong with a P bass and it's tone is different than a jazz.
Why so harsh? If I had asked for advice on which bass to buy for use in a Patsy Cline tribute band, I might well have avoided buying that chrometone five string Thumb.
Voted “other” but recommending a P bass of any kind for you. The American Standards from 2012-2016 are sweet and my suggestion, especially for the used price and good resale value.
With metal and thrash I went with the Spector. Its made for growl and snarl with a slight mid scoop. Finger style or pick, just a killer tone. Great for slapping as well.
Add the extended range needed for those styles of music, the fact they are exceptionally made, and you have a winner
Add the extended range needed for those styles of music, the fact they are exceptionally made, and you have a winner
I would probably advise you to take a look at some of the basses Ibanez offers.
They offer astonishing quality compared to the price they ask for their basses all along their product line, from their budget GIO basses to their upper Premium and Prestige line of basses.
And from a visual perspective I personally really like most of their designs as well.
Judging from the basses you list it seems like you would probably be aiming at their top line of basses.
They offer astonishing quality compared to the price they ask for their basses all along their product line, from their budget GIO basses to their upper Premium and Prestige line of basses.
And from a visual perspective I personally really like most of their designs as well.
Judging from the basses you list it seems like you would probably be aiming at their top line of basses.
Last edited:
The Corvette double buck is pretty gnarly for the type of music you are interested in playing. You may want to also consider a sterling or stingray too. They are both very aggressive sounding. Contrary to popular belief I would say that the P bass IS NOT the best bass for metal.... Motown yes, metal and thrash no. Unless you are Steve Harris I suppose.
- Jul 7, 2010
- 3,346
- 2,254
- 4,961
- Disclosures
- Endorsing Artist for: Duncan Pickups; Line6, Hipshot, GHS Strings, Somnium Guitars
I voted other because I feel that after playing just about every style and layout of basses.....I feel the PJ bass is the best overall setup and style to get...But that is just my opinion.
Good luck on the choice.
Good luck on the choice.
I just think it's fun to hear your opinions.
I'd go for a P bass. You didn't ask people why though, but I'll tell you why.
They're very simple. The tone has been used time and time again over all styles of music, and it's a very basic tone that takes effects well. Additionally, unless you really screw the pooch on your EQ settings, they sit in most band mixes well.
They're very simple. The tone has been used time and time again over all styles of music, and it's a very basic tone that takes effects well. Additionally, unless you really screw the pooch on your EQ settings, they sit in most band mixes well.
There's no voting button for all of them.
I'm thinking based on your music and the fact that you already have a Jazz, something different like a Warwick or the Spector would be the ticket. A Ric is going to be a little limited in terms of tone (what it can do, it can do pretty darn well though - for that classic rock sound). A P Bass is another good choice but I think either of the two choices above would be better basses for the job.
Musicman Stingray has a nice biting tone for metal. Sits a bit different in a mix compared to the others you listed. I myself like a bit more of a smoother sound for metal so my Ibanez ATK has worked well. Good luck!
Good point. I'm leaning more towards Warwick or Spector now.