may have to get a black pearloid some day
Get the black one, you'll be glad you did. I have a midnight wine jazz MIM just like yours (2005). Did the same as you and put a pearloid guard on it. It just never worked for me. Put a black guard on it, and it is one of the best color combinations I've seen.
Have you guys checked out Greasy Grooves? They have a lot of nice pickguards.
I got these for a "strat":
Liberty 2 Graphical Fender Stratocaster SSS 11 hole, Graphical
We the People Graphical Strat Tremolo Cover, Graphical